対局日：2023/07/02 棋戦名：第73回NHK杯1回戦 先手：郷田真隆九段 後手：西川和宏六段 ply=1 pro= +2726FU, com= +7776FU, result= × ply=2 pro= -3334FU, com= -8384FU, result= × ply=3 pro= +2625FU, com= +7776FU, result= × ply=4 pro= -2233KA, com= -2233KA, result= ○ ply=5 pro= +7776FU, com= +7776FU, result= ○ ply=6 pro= -4344FU, com= -4344FU, result= ○ ply=7 pro= +3948GI, com= +3948GI, result= ○ ply=8 pro= -8232HI, com= -8242HI, result= × ply=9 pro= +5968OU, com= +5968OU, result= ○ ply=10 pro= -3142GI, com= -3142GI, result= ○ ply=11 pro= +6878OU, com= +6878OU, result= ○ ply=12 pro= -5162OU, com= -5162OU, result= ○ ply=13 pro= +8877KA, com= +4958KI, result= × ply=14 pro= -6272OU, com= -6272OU, result= ○ ply=15 pro= +7888OU, com= +7888OU, result= ○ ply=16 pro= -7282OU, com= -4243GI, result= × ply=17 pro= +9998KY, com= +9998KY, result= ○ ply=18 pro= -4243GI, com= -9192KY, result= × ply=19 pro= +8899OU, com= +8899OU, result= ○ ply=20 pro= -3435FU, com= -9192KY, result= × ply=21 pro= +7988GI, com= +7988GI, result= ○ ply=22 pro= -3351KA, com= -9192KY, result= × ply=23 pro= +5756FU, com= +5756FU, result= ○ ply=24 pro= -3234HI, com= -3234HI, result= ○ ply=25 pro= +4857GI, com= +4857GI, result= ○ ply=26 pro= -2133KE, com= -2133KE, result= ○ ply=27 pro= +7768KA, com= +6979KI, result= × ply=28 pro= -4445FU, com= -4445FU, result= ○ ply=29 pro= +6979KI, com= +6979KI, result= ○ ply=30 pro= -4152KI, com= -7172GI, result= × ply=31 pro= +4746FU, com= +4746FU, result= ○ ply=32 pro= -4344GI, com= -4354GI, result= × ply=33 pro= +6877KA, com= +2826HI, result= × ply=34 pro= -7172GI, com= -7172GI, result= ○ ply=35 pro= +2524FU, com= +2826HI, result= × ply=36 pro= -2324FU, com= -2324FU, result= ○ ply=37 pro= +2848HI, com= +4958KI, result= × ply=38 pro= -9394FU, com= -3536FU, result= × ply=39 pro= +4645FU, com= +4645FU, result= ○ ply=40 pro= -4445GI, com= -4445GI, result= ○ ply=41 pro= +0023FU, com= +0023FU, result= ○ ply=42 pro= -3536FU, com= -2425FU, result= × ply=43 pro= +3736FU, com= +3736FU, result= ○ ply=44 pro= -0047FU, com= -3436HI, result= × ply=45 pro= +4847HI, com= +4847HI, result= ○ ply=46 pro= -0046FU, com= -3436HI, result= × ply=47 pro= +4748HI, com= +5746GI, result= × ply=48 pro= -3436HI, com= -3436HI, result= ○ ply=49 pro= +2322TO, com= +2322TO, result= ○ ply=50 pro= -3325KE, com= -3626HI, result= × ply=51 pro= +4938KI, com= +0037FU, result= × ply=52 pro= -5133KA, com= -0037FU, result= × ply=53 pro= +7733UM, com= +7733UM, result= ○ ply=54 pro= -3633HI, com= -3633HI, result= ○ ply=55 pro= +0037FU, com= +0037FU, result= ○ ply=56 pro= -0059KA, com= -0036FU, result= × ply=57 pro= +4878HI, com= +0055KA, result= × ply=58 pro= -0036FU, com= -0036FU, result= ○ ply=59 pro= +3736FU, com= +3736FU, result= ○ ply=60 pro= -3336HI, com= -3336HI, result= ○ ply=61 pro= +0037FU, com= +0037FU, result= ○ ply=62 pro= -2537NK, com= -3633HI, result= × ply=63 pro= +2937KE, com= +2937KE, result= ○ ply=64 pro= -5937UM, com= -5937UM, result= ○ ply=65 pro= +3837KI, com= +3837KI, result= ○ ply=66 pro= -3637RY, com= -3637RY, result= ○ ply=67 pro= +5768GI, com= +5768GI, result= ○ ply=68 pro= -4647TO, com= -4647TO, result= ○ ply=69 pro= +7675FU, com= +7675FU, result= ○ ply=70 pro= -6364FU, com= -0064KI, result= × ply=71 pro= +7574FU, com= +7574FU, result= ○ ply=72 pro= -7374FU, com= -7374FU, result= ○ ply=73 pro= +0055KA, com= +0055KA, result= ○ ply=74 pro= -3734RY, com= -3739RY, result= × ply=75 pro= +0023KA, com= +0023KA, result= ○ ply=76 pro= -3436RY, com= -3435RY, result= × ply=77 pro= +5564KA, com= +5564KA, result= ○ ply=78 pro= -0073KI, com= -0073KI, result= ○ ply=79 pro= +6473UM, com= +6473UM, result= ○ ply=80 pro= -7273GI, com= -7273GI, result= ○ ply=81 pro= +0075FU, com= +0075FU, result= ○ ply=82 pro= -7475FU, com= -7475FU, result= ○ ply=83 pro= +7875HI, com= +0074FU, result= × ply=84 pro= -4554GI, com= -0074FU, result= × ply=85 pro= +7573RY, com= +0074FU, result= × ply=86 pro= -8273OU, com= -8273OU, result= ○ ply=87 pro= +0074FU, com= +0074FU, result= ○ ply=88 pro= -7363OU, com= -7363OU, result= ○ ply=89 pro= +0073KE, com= +0082GI, result= × ply=90 pro= -4758TO, com= -0078FU, result= × ply=91 pro= +6877GI, com= +7361NK, result= × ply=92 pro= -0078FU, com= -6171KI, result= × ply=93 pro= +7381NK, com= +7361NK, result= × ply=94 pro= -5242KI, com= -0039HI, result= × ply=95 pro= +7978KI, com= +7978KI, result= ○ ply=96 pro= -0049HI, com= -0076FU, result= × ply=97 pro= +0043FU, com= +0043FU, result= ○ ply=98 pro= -0076FU, com= -4233KI, result= × ply=99 pro= +4342TO, com= +4342TO, result= ○ ply=100 pro= -7677TO, com= -7677TO, result= ○ ply=101 pro= +8877GI, com= +8877GI, result= ○ ply=102 pro= -4942RY, com= -0064GI, result= × ply=103 pro= +0043FU, com= +0043FU, result= ○ ply=104 pro= -4243RY, com= -4272RY, result= × ply=105 pro= +0073KI, com= +0044FU, result= × ply=106 pro= -6352OU, com= -6352OU, result= ○ ply=107 pro= +0064KE, com= +0055KE, result= × ply=108 pro= -5242OU, com= -5242OU, result= ○ ply=109 pro= +0032KI, com= +0034FU, result= × ply=110 pro= -4332RY, com= -4332RY, result= ○ ply=111 pro= +2232TO, com= +2232TO, result= ○ ply=112 pro= -3632RY, com= -3632RY, result= ○ ply=113 pro= +2332UM, com= +2332UM, result= ○ ply=114 pro= -4232OU, com= -4232OU, result= ○ ply=115 pro= +0035HI, com= +0082HI, result= × 先手一致率：39 / 58 67.24% 後手一致率：30 / 57 52.63% 全体一致率：69 / 115 60.00% 解析エンジン名：Gift Ver.1.0.8